BLOG

Flux.1 Takes on Midjourney: The Ultimate Showdown in AI Image Generation!

Aitubo

Aug 30, 2024 • 6 min read

Flux.1 Takes on Midjourney: The Ultimate Showdown in AI Image Generation!

TABLE OF CONTENTS

The Stable Diffusion team can be described in one sentence:
“Together they are a blazing fire, scattered they are a sky full of stars.”
Recently, Robin Rombach, one of the creators of Stable Diffusion, announced his new venture, founding Black Forest Labs and launching their latest AI image generation model, Flux.1.
How impressive is this FLux.1 AI image generation model? Take a look at the results:

*Prompt：a portal into a mythical forest on the wall of my small messy bedroom.*

Some users using Flux.1 have commented that the most impressive feature of Flux.1 AI image generaor is Flux.1's exceptional language understanding and text control capabilities, effectively eliminating the issue of “gibberish.”
Some users have suggested that the Flux.1 AI image generator will outshine both Midjourney and Stable Diffusion, and Flux.1 will emerge as the new dominant force in the AI image generation market.

The key point is that Flux.1 requires no deployment and Flux.1 is currently available for free.
So, how does Flux.1 really perform? Let’s put it to the test and compare Flux.1 with Midjourney online.
Feel free to share your thoughts about this Flux.1 AI image generator and join the discussion in the comments.

Trying to ditch the "Gibberish”

Flux.1 AI image genertor offers three model variants: the most powerful Flux Pro version, the development-focused Flux Dev version, and the fastest Flux Schnell version. All of these Flux.1 versions are available on Aitubo and Replicate
Free trial link:
https://aitubo.ai/flux-image-generator/
https://replicate.com/black-forest-labs/flux-pro

We'll start by evaluating Flux.1 from Aitubo on its own, focusing on Flux.1's text generation and multi-style capabilities.

*Prompt：realistic minion holding a sign that says "hello!" in his hand, quality details, hyper realistic, high definition,8K, photo.*

*Prompt :A high-resolution photograph of a weathered, historical brick wall with a rough, hammer-carved inscription of "always believe in yourself"*

*Prompt :Steve Jobs wears T-shirt with the text“stay hungry stay foolish”, hand write, cinematic, photo.*

*Prompt :A vintage watering can holds blue roses, soft tulips, and baby’s breath, making it perfect for decorating a table.*

*Prompt : Morgan Freeman caricature, in the style of michael hussar, caricature faces, angelina wrona, dark white and azure, expressive eyes, celebrity-portraits, high resolution，1:1*

*Prompt : A beautiful European woman holding a bouquet of flowers, German model, realistic photo style, full-body shot.*

Overall, Flux.1's text generation capabilities are truly impressive. The image generated by Flux.1 of the Minion holding a "hello!" sign, with clear text and correct spelling, Flux.1 effectively addresses the common issue of AI image generator struggling with text.

Epic Showdown of Two Powerhouses

Next, let's pit the powerful AI image generator Flux.1 Pro against Midjourney in a head-to-head comparison. (The image on the left is Flux.1 Pro from Aitubo, and the one on the right is Midjourney.)

*Prompt: "sunshine" letters made by balloons, realistic, simple background.*

Prompt: A beautiful Asian woman with long hair, wearing an open white shirt and beige pants, sits on the floor in front of the viewer, looking at them with soft lighting. The background features a light gray wall, green plants, wooden furniture, and warm tones,1:1

*Prompt：Adult boy, successful person, Asian, happy, solid color background, C4D rendering, Pixar，1:1*

*Prompt：macro photography of a miniature little village on top of a flower,1:1*

*Prompt：An oil pianting of a black greyhound dog lay down in a field of grass and lots of flowers of different colors. There is a sunset back in the field,1:1*

After comparing Flux.1 with Midjourney, it’s clear that each has its strengths.
Flux.1 AI image generaotr shows greater prowess in text understanding and adherence to prompts. For instance, in the “sunshine” text generated with the “climate” theme, Flux.1 clearly incorporates balloon elements, showcasing Flux.1's effective handling of textual details, which is really impressive among AI image generaors.
On the other hand, Midjourney excels in aesthetics and texture, as exemplified by the oil painting-style image of a “dog lying in a field.” The atmosphere of Midjourney’s images is rich, with bold and pleasing colors that make the AI image generaotr's presence almost imperceptible.

Creative Comparisons from Users

User Dogan Ural also conducted a comparison between the Flux.1 AI image generator and Midjourney
For instance:

This user noted that the Flux.1 AI image generator , hailed as the "Midjourney Killer," indeed has notable strengths, including exceptionally detailed images, strong prompt adherence, and diverse styles.
User @javilopen finds that Flux.1 excels in interpreting complex prompts.
He provided an example for comparison: the Flux.1 image features a real photograph of a blonde girl in a bikini on a tropical island, while the right image shows a dog-headed girl in a bikini on a tropical island, mimicking the "blonde girl" theme.
Here’s the final result, it's clear that Flux.1 is better at conprehending the text between the two AI image generators

For example:

*Prompt: huge bird inside a bottle, raining inside the room and a boy with an umbrella, studio ghibli style.*

Flux.1 also excels at creating surreal images.

After Flux.1 burst onto the scene,the lab that created Flux.1 has stated that their next goal is to release a state-of-the-art text-to-video model for everyone to use. Excitement is definitely warranted!

Conclusion

Flux.1 AI image generator places a greater emphasis on accurately reproducing realistic details in image generation. Whether it’s the play of light and shadow, the texture of materials, or the expressions and movements of characters, Flux.1 can more precisely simulate the subtle nuances of the real world. This results in Flux.1's images that are not only visually appealing but also convey a sense of authenticity, making it feel as if the scenes or characters are right in front of you.

In contrast, while Midjourney excels in creativity and artistic expression, particularly in creating images with a fantastical or abstract style, it falls somewhat short in terms of realism and naturalness in the finer details. The generated images often bear noticeable traces of artistic manipulation, which may not be suitable for scenarios requiring a high degree of photorealism.

Overall, if your goal is to produce highly realistic and natural images, Flux.1 is clearly the better choice of the two Ai image generators. Flux.1 achieves a close approximation of the real world’s visual effects while still maintaining artistic beauty.

If you want to try AI image generator Flux.1, Aitubo is a great choice for it's convenience and comprehensiveness. If you have any insights or thoughts about Flux.1, please let me know in the comments！